Skip Navigation
October 7, 2015 | 24th Tishrei 5776

Reform Movement Reacts to Palestinian "Unity Government"

Rabbi Jacobs: "This much is clear: no one who loves Israel, or cares about the Palestinian people, or both, can afford to close doors right now. However daunting, this must be a moment when all parties stop taking unilateral actions..."

Contact: Annette Powers

June 5, 2014, New York, NY – In response to the formation of a Palestinian "unity government," Union for Reform Judaism (URJ) President Rabbi Rick Jacobs, issued the following statement:

"If the achievement of a real – enforceable, fair, lasting – peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians were not an existential question for Israel, this would be an understandable time for American Jews and other lovers of Israel to throw up our hands and walk away from the peace process. Perhaps that is why the Psalmist teaches us to "seek peace and pursue it," calling on us to not give up on seeking peace even in those moments when it is beyond our ability to see.

This week's formalization of a Palestinian "unity government" is a particularly disheartening development. It is simply impossible to see a government that includes Hamas, which remains committed to Israel's destruction, as a partner for peace. There should be no illusions about Hamas' nature; it remains a terrorist organization not a government.

This decision by the Palestinians comes on the heels of the collapse of the admirable and dogged effort by Secretary of State John Kerry to bring Israel and the Palestinians to the negotiating table.

This much is clear: no one who loves Israel, or cares about the Palestinian people, or both, can afford to close doors right now. However daunting, this must be a moment when all parties stop taking unilateral actions – such as the creation of a "unity government" – that make the achievement of an agreement less, rather than more, possible.

This is also true for the Israeli government, who reacted to the Palestinian "unity government" by announcing additional settlements in the West Bank. Such construction is precisely the type of action that impedes the possibility of progress. And on a tactical level, it makes it that much more difficult to build support for Israel at a time when efforts to isolate her are increasing internationally.

Israel, the U.S., and the international community must be prepared to respond when actions from the new "unity government" endanger Israel or its citizens. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was correct to say that he holds President Mahmud Abbas responsible for any rocket fire that comes from Gaza into Israel. That is the logical result of a "unity government" under President Abbas' leadership. But the response to such actions should not be the erection of unnecessary hurdles on the arduous, and often hard to discern, path to a potential peace agreement."


Norman Sider

June 7, 2014
07:53 PM

If, as the government of Israel states, the proposed location for new construction in the West Bank is in that part of the West Bank that is generally understood will be retained by Israel should the PA and Israel sign a peace agreement, then the announcement of the plan by the Israeli government is not an impediment to peace. Of course, even if it is, it is hardly on the scale of the PA's decision to kiss and make up with Hamas.


Leone Baum

June 9, 2014
07:34 AM

Senior Citizen

I witnessed the joyful, bloody birth of Israel working in the office of the Jewish National Fund in New York City in 1948. As an American Jew, since then I have supported and hoped for survival of the tiny piece of land that is the only true home for us.

Rabbi Jacobs last paragraph says it all. It is time to try to work out a peaceful solution to the millenniums old conundrum. Maybe we need to anoint the seventy tribal leaders we read about in last week's Torah portion.



June 13, 2014
12:21 AM

Rabbi Jacobs joins Rabbi Yoffe as naive excusers of Pal provocation. When it comes to Israel, The Reform Movement is bereft of leadership.


Martin W.

June 16, 2014
08:10 AM

Where is the statement on the so called unity government now that three teens have been kidnapped by these peace lovers?


Comments left on this website are monitored. By posting a comment you are in agreement with Terms & Conditions.

URJ logo

Donate Now



Multimedia Icon Multimedia:  Photos  |  Videos  |  Podcasts  |  Webinars
Bookmark and Share About Us  |  Careers  |  Privacy Policy
Copyright Union for Reform Judaism 2015.  All Rights Reserved