Why I'm Staying in the Room for Donald Trump's AIPAC Address

Inside Leadership

Why I'm Staying in the Room for Donald Trump's AIPAC Address

I will be in the arena today at AIPAC’s Policy Conference to hear Donald Trump and the other Presidential candidates who present at AIPAC.

It was a difficult decision for me. I understand why many will choose not to attend or to walk out silently – I, however, have decided that it is important to be present, to show Mr. Trump that we demand clearly articulated foreign policies and quality leadership from all the candidates. He owes us an explanation and an audience.

To make this decision, I drew on an experience I had 40 years ago. In the spring of 1976, I was invited to Washington, D.C., to represent NFTY: The Reform Jewish Youth Movement at a meeting of the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations to meet with each of the presidential candidates. Surprisingly, Alabama Governor George Wallace agreed to attend this gathering, marking the first time he’d ever addressed a Jewish group. I’ll never forget him being carried up the steps of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, where the 1964 Civil Rights Act and 1965 Voting Rights Act were drafted, and into a room where I sat alongside about 30 middle-aged Jewish men.

To our disbelief, Wallace apologized for his years of racist policies and behavior, asking our forgiveness for his anti-Semitic and vile bigotry. Truly, it was an historic event.

Today, when faced with the decision whether to be in the room when current presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks to a Jewish audience, I looked back on this experience and realized that if we had not invited Wallace, we would have given up our influence and power. We would have simply dismissed his bad behavior rather than, at the very least, demanding that he explain it. It was a testament to our collective influence, confidence, and power that Wallace was included in the day’s events. The gathering stood and clapped because our values of tzedek (righteousness), b'tzelem elohim (being created in God's image), and t'shuvah (forgiveness) were upheld.

I am deeply troubled by Mr. Trump's vituperative speech: by his Islamophobia; his disdain for women, Hispanics, and Muslims; his incitement of violence; and his demeanor. These all go against the Jewish and American values that I hold most dear. Yet I will remain, silently, in the arena tonight because I want to be able to meet with Mr. Trump and to say that I was there, that I did not leave. I hope I will hear him outline his policies regarding Israel and the Middle East and apologize for his rough and unpresidential language. I want to be in the room to be able to say that I heard from him in person, not via the media.

Whether you choose to remain in the arena or quietly and respectfully leave before the candidate speaks – whether in your synagogue or in your home, whether in the days to come or the months of the campaign season ahead – our Jewish tradition guides our understanding of what we expect from our leaders when it comes to appropriate standards of ethical discourse and policies that reflect our core values.

Have something to say about this post? Join the conversation in The Tent, the social network for congregational leaders of the Reform Movement. You can also tweet us or tell us how you feel on Facebook.

Daryl Messinger, chair of the North American board of trustees of the Union for Reform Judaism, has served on the URJ board for 15 years and in Reform Movement affiliated organizations in a wide variety of roles. A dynamic leader with a track record of sustained involvement and success, she has recently concluded her service as chair of the Reform Pension Board, which serves Reform Movement professionals and has a total portfolio of more than $1.2 billion.

She has been a key partner in helping to implement the URJ’s Campaign for Youth Engagement and in shaping the URJ’s 2020 Vision strategic plan. She previously served as chair for URJ Camp Newman's advisory board (in Santa Rosa, CA), and as a vice chair and an assistant treasurer of the URJ. 

Messinger’s congregational lay leadership experience is extensive. She served, at the age of 36, as the youngest president of her then 1,100-member congregation, Congregation Beth Am in Los Altos Hills, CA. She has served in a variety of roles there including as treasurer, chair of its capital campaign, chair of the rabbinic search committee, and volunteer coordinator of an innovative family education program.

Daryl Messinger
What's New
Activists marching in a rally and holding a Religious Action Center banner
Jan 19, 2020|Arno Rosenfeld

Find More in The Tent

Learn more about this exciting new platform, where Reform congregational leaders connect with colleagues and peers who have similar concerns, interests and responsibilities.